Editor's note: Enroll today in our brand new Mastering Lightroom Classic Secrets course to learn all of Lightroom's hidden tips, tricks and secrets! Limited time only. Thanks for reading, Andrew.
Texture is a key element of the black and white landscape. It’s so important that it may be the factor that decides whether you process a landscape photo in color or black and white.
When you’re photographing a landscape, look for elements that contain interesting textures. If you can include them in the composition you have the potential for a good black and white photo, especially if the scene has other elements that work well in monochrome like tonal contrast, strong shapes or patterns, good foreground interest or leading lines.
Take a look at this photo, taken in Andalusia in Spain. The landscape was dry, parched of recent rain. The sun was setting, and the light was beautiful, but the thing that really caught my eye was the beautiful textures in the dry earth and the ruined farmhouse. Black and white is perfect for emphasizing that.
Here’s another black and white landscape that makes good use of texture. I came across these farm buildings on a walk through the country. It was mid-afternoon on a bright but cloudy day. Not inspirational light for working in color, but that doesn’t matter for black and white because this photo is about texture rather than light or color. The grass, silos and sky all have interesting textures, and so does the farm machinery in the foreground and the buildings in the background.
By the way, I didn’t have my X-T1 with me and I made this photo with my iPhone.
Texture can even become the main subject of the photo. I made this landscape detail photo while walking around the ruins of a roman town in southern Spain. I wanted to emphasize the shapes and textures of the rocks and black and white is the perfect medium for that.
I took a similar approach in this triptych of photos, taken in a gully close to the location of the abandoned farmhouse in the earlier photo. I found the shapes and textures of the rocks interesting, and made a series of square format photos as we walked along the gully. They look interesting presented together.
Texture and long exposure photography
One of the features of long exposure photography is that it creates a contrast between heavily textured and lightly textured parts of the scene. The photos I’ve shown you so far have all been heavily textured.
But this one, taken with a shutter speed of 180 seconds, is different. The sea and clouds moved during the three minutes the shutter was open and are blurred. The photo has heavily textured cliffs and rock formations, but smooth sea and sky.
Here’s another version, taken just a few minutes before, with a shutter speed of 1/2 second. In this version the texture of the sea and clouds is clearly visible.
This is a good example of the relationship between time (shutter speed) and texture. When photographing water and clouds, longer shutter speeds reduce texture. The longer the shutter speed, the less texture.
That’s an important tool for landscape photographers to learn to use. There are times when using a neutral density filter and a shutter speed of several minutes gives beautiful results. Equally, there are times when shutter speeds of half a second or one second create interesting lines and patterns of movement in the sea. An awareness of the tool at your disposal (in this case shutter speed) and its effect on the landscape helps you decide how to use it.
Texture in post-processing
Once you have taken a photo that you intend to convert to black and white and make use of the texture then it becomes interesting to look at the tools that you can use to do so.
Emphasizing texture in Lightroom Classic
The main tools for bringing out textures in Lightroom Classic are Clarity and Texture (increasing contrast can also help). Let’s take the following image as an example. This is how it looks after being converted to black and white, but without any action taken to emphasize the texture. It’s another long exposure photo (shutter speed 160 seconds) taken in the early evening in a seaside town in northern Spain called Tapia de Casariego.
You can see we have a contrast in texture – the sea and sky are smooth (thanks to the long exposure) but the jetty in the background and the concrete in the foreground have lots of texture. The more we can emphasize the textures here, the greater the contrast between the textured surfaces and the smooth water and sky, and the greater the visual impact of the photo.
This I how I did it.
1. I increased Clarity globally. The first step was to go to the Basic Panel and move the Clarity slider right. In simple terms (the actual process is a little more complex) the Clarity slider increases the apparent contrast of mid-tones, which in turn makes these areas appear sharper and brings out textures.
2. I adjusted Clarity locally. Next, I used the Adjustment Brush to select the areas that I wanted to make further adjustments to individually. You can see the two adjustments I made in this screenshot.
With both selections I increased Clarity and also made some adjustments to brightness and contrast. The latter action was required because increasing Clarity usually makes the selected area darker or brighter (the result seems to depend on the content of the photo). There’s no set formula here – it’s a matter of adding Clarity and adjusting the tonal sliders until it looks good to your eye.
You could also potentially use the Adjustment Brush to select the sea and sky and apply a negative Clarity or contrast setting to decrease texture in those areas, although I didn’t do it with this image.
This is the result of my adjustments.
Emphasizing texture in Silver Efex Pro 2
There are several black and white plugins available for Lightroom Classic and one feature they all share is that they have more refined tools than Lightroom Classic for bringing out texture. This is because texture is an important part of all black and white photos (not just landscapes).
Let’s take a look at Silver Efex Pro. It doesn’t have a Clarity slider. Instead it uses an adjustment called Structure, which has a similar, but more subtle, effect. A key difference is that you can apply it independently to shadows, mid-tones and highlights, giving you more control over the areas of the photo affected. There’s also a Fine Structure slider for applying structure to areas of fine detail.
1. Global adjustments. Under Structure I set Highlights to -100%, which had a minor effect on the sea and clouds, and Shadows to 100%, which had the greatest effect on the dark tones in the jetty in the background. I left the Midtones slider alone as using it applied Structure to the sea and sky (as well as the concrete in the foreground) which I didn’t want.
2. Local adjustments. Silver Efex Pro has a completely different system than Lightroom Classic for applying local adjustments. The Nik Collection plugins use a system called Control Points.
A Control Point is the centre of a circle within which you can make tonal adjustments. The adjustment is applied to tones similar in brightness and color to the pixels underneath the Control Point.
For example, if you place a Control Point over a dark tone, then increase the brightness, only the dark tones within the circle are adjusted. Light tones are not unaffected.
I placed three Control Points over the concrete in the foreground, and increased Structure and Fine Structure in each one. This screenshot shows the mask created by the Control Points. Areas in white are affected most by the adjustments, areas in black are unaffected.
Here’s the result.
Here’s the version created with Lightroom Classic again, to give you an idea of the difference.
Whether you are in the field evaluating a scene for its potential as a black and white landscape, or looking through old photos to see if any have potential for converting to monochrome, texture is one of the most important elements to consider.
I’ve only touched on post-production techniques here, but hopefully you can see that it is possible to spend quite some time refining a black and white landscape in Lightroom Classic (or a plugin like Silver Efex Pro) to make the most out of the natural texture of the scene.