Editor's note: It's time to master your black and white photography skills! You can grab our new video course The Art of Black and White in Lightroom Classic now for just $15 (normal price $20) with the code march5. Thanks for reading, Andrew.
Before we look at how to add keywords to photos in Lightroom (covered in lesson three) let’s consider how you can choose your keywords in the first place. Adding keywords to photos is just a mechanical process that can be learned. It’s more important to make sure you’re using the right ones.
As you can imagine, adding lots of keywords to your photos without thinking about the relationships between them can quickly lead to a chaotic approach that hinders rather than helps your search.
For example, which keywords would you add to this photo – ‘watermelon’, ‘watermelons’, ‘melon’ or ‘melons’ ?
Let’s say you used the keyword ‘watermelon’ for this photo and ‘melon’ for a similar one. If you made a search using the keyword ‘watermelon’ the photo with ’melon’ wouldn’t show up in the results. Neither would it show up if somebody searched for photos of watermelons in a photo stock library. That’s not helpful, so you need to make sure it doesn’t happen. You can prevent it by using keyword lists, Keyword sets and keyword hierarchies.
Using keyword lists
Imagine you are a portrait photographer and you need a fast way of searching your portraits. It’s important that you have a consistent approach so you don’t accidentally omit any portraits from your search. That’s where putting together a list of keywords to use for your portraits helps. A list might look something like this:
black and white
This is known in the keywording world as a flat list, to differentiate it from a hierarchical list (see below).
Every time you add keywords to a new portrait, you simply pick the ones from this list that apply. That avoids confusion caused by using different keywords – for instance, ‘man’ instead of ‘male’, or ‘B&W’ instead of ‘black and white’.
This is also known as using a controlled vocabulary.
You can adapt a sample list like this to your requirements. Let’s say you have a need to search your portraits to find photos of women with a specific hair color. In that case you could include keywords like ‘red hair’, ‘blond hair’ and ‘brown hair’ in your list. You could add eye colors as well (‘blue eyes’, ‘brown eyes’ etc.). Then if you ever need to search for portraits of a red-haired woman with blue eyes it should be easy.
This screenshot shows the result of a search for black and white portraits of women made using keywords.
Personal vs. public keywords
You are probably beginning to see why I recommend not rushing into using keywords. You’ll need a bit of time to figure out what your search requirements are and what keywords will serve them best.
Another thing you need to consider is whether your keywords are for your personal use or for public use.
Personal keywords are designed to help you find photos quickly and easily. They are for you, not for other people.
Public keywords are for helping other people search your photos, either in a stock photo library or on a photo sharing website like Flickr or 500px.
This screenshot shows keywords picked up by Flickr and converted to tags.
With personal keywords the question is what’s the minimum number of keywords you need to enable you to search your photos quickly and effectively? Don’t forget, some keywords are redundant because Lightroom lets you combine other search criteria with keywords. For example, you could add the keyword ‘2017’ to all photos taken in the year 2017. But there’s not much point as you can limit all searches to a given date range.
You might also prefer to search for location using the Map module rather than using keywords. It may be easier to drag your photos to a location on the map after you have imported them than to add keywords. Or you might have a camera with GPS that embeds the location data automatically, saving you time.
These are the sort of things that you need to think about when creating personal keyword lists. Remember, the only requirement is that the system works for you and makes it easy to search your photos. It’s a good idea not to overcomplicate things by including too many personal keywords in your list. The more you have, the longer it takes to decide which ones to add.
With public keywords, especially for photos that you intend to submit to a stock photo library, you need to take other people’s requirements into consideration. A photo stock library may have a list of keywords it prefers you to use (a controlled vocabulary), it may also have a recommended minimum and maximum number of keywords you can add to a photo.
You also need to think in terms of conceptual and emotional keywords as well as descriptive ones. If you have a photo of two people drinking coffee together, for example, then you might add keywords like ‘friendship’ or ‘togetherness’. You have to think about what concepts potential buyers need to illustrate. A Google search brings up several websites that sell keyword lists if you need help keywording stock photos.
Using keyword hierarchies
Another way of using keywords is to arrange them in hierarchies. Here’s an example of a keyword hierarchy based on location.
North America > United States > New York State > New York City
You can see that the keywords are arranged in a hierarchy following this criteria:
Continent > Country > State > City
Using keyword hierarchies like this in Lightroom has three advantages.
1. It organizes keywords so they are easier to find in your lists. Lightroom lists keywords in alphabetical order. That means, using the above example, that the keyword ‘United States’ would be separated from the others, making it hard to find.
This is most likely to be a problem if you have a long list of public keywords.
2. You can add multiple keywords to your photos in one go. For example, with the above keyword hierarchy when you add ‘New York City’ as a keyword Lightroom automatically adds ‘North America’, ‘United States’ and ‘New York State’.
3. You can handle keywords with different meanings. Let’s say you’re a stock photographer with photos of a both a chest of drawers and a man’s chest in your collection. A hierarchy lets you distinguish between both types of chest. It looks something like this.
People > body parts > chest
Furniture > chest
When you do a search for photos of a chest, Lightroom lets you select which type of chest you want to search for.
Using Keyword sets
Most of the benefits of keyboard hierarchies listed apply to stock photographers. If you’re using personal keywords then you are going to use far fewer keywords. In that case it may be easier to arrange keywords in sets rather than hierarchies.
For example, the keywords in the sequence North America > United States > New York State > New York City could be used in Keyword sets that looks something like this.
Keyword set 1:
Keyword set 2:
New York State
Keyword set 3:
New York City
Keyword sets don’t have to be exhaustive. There is no point in adding the names of cities you have never visited to Keyword set 3, for example. They are just a way of grouping keywords to make them easier to find than they would be in an alphabetical list.
The only limitation of Keyword sets is that Lightroom doesn’t let you add more than nine keywords.
Make your own keyword lists
If you’re new to using keywords now is a good time to make some keyword lists, including hierarchies (if needed) and Keyword sets. The best approach is to use Excel or Numbers to keep a record of the keywords you want to use. If you’ve already started using keywords, but are struggling to use them effectively, the same exercise should be helpful.
Keyword case study
I’m going to leave with you an example left in a comment by a reader on an article I wrote. Thank you Pavol Sojak for letting me use it in this article! If you like Pavol’s idea don’t forget you don’t have to follow it to the letter. You should adapt it to you own needs, using his list as a starting point.
“My keyword list is organized in four main topics:
Then the structure goes on:
Location: I have a group for each country, e.g. Belgium, Slovakia, Sweden, Finland. Under each country I have names of cities. For some cities like Bratislava (where I live) I have additional locations defined, for other cities I do not need this.
People: I have groups for Family, Friends, Neighbors, School and Celebrities. Under those I have individual name of peoples or just their surnames.
Subjects: I have groups like Fauna (with some sub-level split for more photographed animals), Flora, Landscape (split by Bridges, Castles, Cityscape, Natural landscape), Food, and some other generic subjects like Panoramas, HDR, etc.
Timeline_Events: I have groups like Christmas, New Years Eve, Easter, TEDx, Vacation, Birthday, or other events I have photos from.
Every time I assign keywords I know I should pick at least one from the four main topics – Location, People, Subject and Timeline_Event.
After some time using this it’s really straightforward.”
The next steps
If you’d like to learn more about Lightroom I suggest you sign up to our Introducing Lightroom Classic free email course. We’ll send five free Lightroom Classic lessons straight to your inbox! And while you’re here, don’t forget to check out our Mastering Lightroom Classic ebook bundle (see below).
The Mastering Lightroom Classic ebook bundle
It’s time to take the next step on your Lightroom Classic journey!
These ebooks guide you through every aspect of Lightroom Classic with over 730 pages of easy to follow, clearly written instructions.
Learn how to import and organize your photos, create beautiful printed books and websites, and become a Lightroom ninja in the Develop module.
You can buy the ebooks individually for $15 each or the bundle for just $29 (saving a whopping $16 over the individual prices!).
Black & White in Lightroom Classic
Discover how to make beautiful black and white photos in Lightroom Classic with our new video course The Art of Black & White in Lightroom Classic. Get 25% off if you buy before March 31 with the code march5!