Are You Making These Black & White Photography Mistakes?

Are You Making These Common Black And White Photography Mistakes?

Editor's note: This month only – take the next step on your creative journey and enroll in the Finding your Creative Voice 2024 course for just $25! Click here to learn more. Thanks for reading, Andrew.

In this article we’re going to take a light-hearted look at the most common black and white photography mistakes that people make. Of course, I’m sure you’re not making any of them, but it never hurts to check!

Mistake #1: Trying to save photos by making them black and white

For some reason some photographers seem to think that converting to black and white is what you do with their worse photos, as if that somehow makes them okay.

Let’s be clear about this – black and white is not a method for rescuing poorly crafted color photos. If your photo is bad in color, it will be bad in black and white too (although sometimes you may come across a photo that works better in black and white for compositional reasons).

Mistake #2: Not having a strong composition

Black and white is a strong, bold, graphic medium that relies on excellent composition and lighting to work. You get the best results when you shoot for black and white intentionally, as this lets you build your composition around the principles of simplicity, texture and tonal contrast.

If your color photo doesn’t have these elements then it probably won’t work in black and white. You’ll just get frustrated if you try and convert it because you’ll get a poor result.

Here are two examples. In the first I’d decided in advance that I wanted to photograph this monument in black and white. I’d also decided that I wanted graphic compositions that juxtaposed its light toned stonework against a deep blue sky. This enabled me to think in black and white, visualizing the final result while I worked.

Black and white architectural photo

In the second I used black and white because of the textures in the stones on the beach, and in the cliff face and concrete block behind the dancer. The juxtaposition of several interesting textured surfaces, and the contrast with the dancer’s skin, make the photo.

Black and white photo of dancer

Mistake #3: Not shooting in the best light

One of the advantages of black and white is that you can often shoot in lighting conditions not suitable for color photography. For example, on a cloudy day you can create beautiful black and white seascapes with a tripod and neutral density filters (this is called long exposure photography, there’s an example below). Yet, in color, you would really need to shoot close to dawn or sunset to make the most of the scene.

Black and white long exposure photo

But what some people do is use black and white to shoot in lighting conditions that are simply unsuitable for the subject. Using black and white isn’t the solution. The important skill is in matching the light to the subject. This takes a while to learn but it’s very important. Don’t be lazy just because it’s black and white.

Mistake #4: Shooting in JPEG format

Shooting in JPEG format is probably the worse thing you could do for your black and white photography.

To understand why, you need to appreciate the difference between Raw files and JPEGs.

• Raw files contain all the information captured by your camera’s sensor.

• JPEGs only contains a fraction of that information.

• A Raw file is not a finished picture file. It has to be processed (using an app that understands the format like Lightroom Classic or Adobe Camera Raw) and converted to a JPEG or TIFF file before other apps can use it.

• A JPEG is a universally recognized photo file. Your camera takes the information captured by the sensor, processes it (much like you would do with a Raw file in Lightroom Classic, but according to the camera’s built-in parameters), compresses it, discards the unused information, and saves it in the JPEG format.

Advantages of shooting RAW

Using the Raw format gives you the following advantages.

You have more control: You process the file yourself, rather than letting the camera do it. You can develop it to your taste from a stylistic point of view. Using Raw lets you interpret the file as many ways as you want. Using JPEG means the file gets interpreted one way only – the way the camera does it.

There’s more data: The Raw file contains much more information than a JPEG, especially in the highlights and shadows, that you can draw out when you process the file. The extra information helps prevent banding in areas of smooth continuous tone like clear skies.

You can adjust sharpness: JPEG files created by your camera are sharpened. The sharpening limits the amount you can change tonal values before introducing halos and artefacts. Yes, you can turn JPEG sharpening off in-camera – but how many people bother?

The RAW format keeps the color info: Raw files contain all the color information captured by the sensor, so you can create a color version of the photo in Lightroom Classic as well.

Using Raw let me create both a color and black and white version of the photo below in Lightroom Classic, without any loss of image quality.

Black and white photography mistakes

The software gets better every year: The version of Lightroom Classic you use in five or 10 years time will be much better than the current one. With Raw, you can take advantage of these new improved tools and redevelop your images in the future.

So please, don’t use the JPEG format any more for black and white photography.

Mistake #5: Not developing the photos properly

Before digital cameras and Lightroom Classic came along, many pro photographers used a professional printer to print their images. Making top quality black and white prints in the darkroom is hard, and it was logical to outsource the job to an expert.

This was a beneficial arrangement that let photographers concentrate full-time on photography and left printing to the specialists. Perhaps the best known pro printer in the UK is Robin Bell, who has worked with big names such as David Bailey, Terry O’Neil, and Eve Arnold.

Nowadays it is much easier to create beautiful black and white images in programs like Lightroom Classic, Photoshop, or Silver Efex Pro than it is to master the chemical darkroom process. But, sadly, many photographers don’t get to grips with the basics. The result is that their black and white photos are not nearly as good as they could be.

Learn to use Lightroom Classic to develop black and white photos

My suggestion is that you start by learning how to use Lightroom Classic properly to convert color photos to black and white. It makes sense to do as much work as you can in Lightroom Classic because you can only send photos to plugins by converting them to a format like 16 bit TIFF.

Once you’ve mastered Lightroom Classic you can download the trial version of a plugin like Silver Efex Pro or Exposure X. The main benefit of these plugins is that they have more tools than Lightroom Classic for converting photos to black and white.

For example, Silver Efex Pro has better tools than Lightroom Classic for emphasizing the textures in your photos. I developed the photos below in Silver Efex Pro. You can’t create the same effects in Lightroom Classic.

Black and white photos developed in Silver Efex Pro 2

Learn more: A Brief Guide To Silver Efex Pro 2

Topaz B&W Effects (sadly no longer available) lets you emulate antique processes such as cyanotype, van dyke brown and albumen printing. I developed this photo using a van dyke brown preset. Again, it’s a unique look that you can’t create in Lightroom Classic alone.

Black and white photo made in Topaz B&W Effects

Learn more: How To Bring Old Processes Back To Life With Topaz B&W Effects

Final thoughts

This article is a bit tongue-in-cheek but hopefully you get the idea – some photographers have interesting misconceptions about black and white photography that prevent them from creating good images.

Black and white photography ebook

The Magic of Black & White: 50 Assignments ebook

Perfect your black and white photography skills with my ebook The Magic of Black & White: 50 Assignments. It’s like a photography workshop in your pocket, filled with a year’s worth of creative briefs, ideas, challenges, assignments and projects that will help you grow as a black and white photographer.

Finding Your Creative Voice course

Introducing Lightroom Classic ebookThanks for reading. You can get more great articles and tips about photography in my popular Mastering Photography email newsletter. Join today and I’ll send you 47 PhotoTips cards and my ebook Introducing Lightroom Classic . Over 30,000 photographers subscribe. Enter your email now and join us.

About Andrew S. Gibson

Andrew S. Gibson is a writer with a camera. He started writing about photography while traveling in Bolivia, and has been published in many prestigious photography magazines including EOS magazine, where he worked as a Writer and Technical Editor for two years. He lives in south Devon in the UK and is inspired by meeting new people, seeing new places and having new experiences. Check out his photography ebooks here.

Leave a Comment